SHARE Share Button Share Button SHARE

Lawyers: Amish should get own court program

LEGAL SYSTEM

They say Lancaster County breeder accused of killing puppies has been improperly denied entry to diversionary program twice This case is particularly troubling as Lancaster County sees a lot of animal abuse surrounding the sale of dogs.

JONATHAN BERGMUELLER

PENNLIVE.COM

When a Lancaster County detective asked John Stoltzfus how he killed four unwanted puppies in October 2023, he told them, “We have a way of doing it. We took good care of them,” according to charging documents.

Now, after two years and two failed attempts to get Stoltzfus into a diversionary court program, his attorneys say Stoltzfus humanely, painlessly and instantaneously euthanized the puppies in a manner consistent with Pennsylvania law.

Neither party is providing specifics as to how they say Stoltzfus killed the puppies. But in the wake of the rejections, the Amish dog breeder’s lawyers are calling for unconventional solutions to address a cultural disconnect between the Amish and the wider American culture.

Stoltzfus, 48, of New Holland, is facing four felony aggravated cruelty to animals charges for killing the dogs, which were a mix of poodle and Old English sheepdog. He later laid their bodies in a compost pile on his property, police said. “Black puppies are not selling,” Stoltzfus told two witnesses, saying he “put them to sleep,” according to police.

Stoltzfus’ attorney told PennLive: “The idea that the Amish would be mean to their animals is ridiculous,” Robert Barnes said. “That they’re mean, cruel or violent is preposterous.”

Barnes, a lawyer from Los Angeles, has represented several high-profile national clients. At one point

— Heather Adams,

Lancaster County district attorney

he sat at the defense table with Kyle Rittenhouse, who was acquitted of murdering two unarmed people at a Black Lives Matter protest in 2020; and was also on Infowars host Alex Jones’ defense team over Jones’ claims the 2012 Sandy Hook school shooting was a hoax.

More recently, Barnes has taken to representing Amish clients. He defended Lancaster County farmer Amos Miller in a lawsuit filed by the federal government over food safety laws and later defended Reuben King, a Lancaster County farmer who sold thousands of guns without a license to do so.

Trying to prevent a chilling effect

Barnes, joined by his comrade Bradford Geyer, told PennLive the Amish have been ingrained in centuries of tradition that have been outpaced by modern law and ethics — especially as it concerns animal rights.

Stoltzfus, a farmer with no criminal record, was transparent with the Pennsylvania SPCA and law enforcement officials about how he put the puppies down, Barnes and Geyer said. They said he believed the manner in which he put the puppies down was legal.

It is illegal to intentionally, knowingly or recklessly mistreat, overload, beat, abandon or abuse an animal under Pennsylvania’s animal cruelty law. When those actions cause the death of an animal, it escalates the crime to aggravated animal cruelty — the offense Stoltzfus is charged with.

Pennsylvania’s laws on the destruction of animals identifies chemical euthanasia as the required method of putting animals down and requires it to be used by licensed technicians or veterinarians.

Under the Pennsylvania Code, only a licensed veterinarian or a licensed euthanasia technician can euthanize a small domestic animal using approved injectable solution, and it must be done in a humane manner to minimize pain, fright and anxiety.

Barnes said the hang-up isn’t that Stoltzfus euthanized the dogs — it’s that he euthanized them without the presence of a licensed veterinarian, Barnes said. Under Pennsylvania’s euthanasia laws, a licensed veterinarian needs to be present for euthanasia to be legal at commercial kennels.

That didn’t happen here. Stoltzfus put the puppies down in his own backyard by himself, and the district attorney’s office is treating the case like a crime. But all that serves to do is teach the Amish not to call the local veterinarian or police, Barnes said.

“Don’t call anyone because they’ll try to get you imprisoned,” Barnes said. “It’s exactly the wrong message you should be sending.”

“Its an increasing concern in the Amish community,” Barnes said. “They don’t know any given day whether something that’s been their tradition for centuries is something that might get them thrown into prison.”

It’s exactly that outcome that Barnes and Geyer are trying to avoid.

Diversionary court for the Amish?

Stoltzfus’ attorneys have made two bids to try to get him into a diversionary court program to resolve the charges without serious consequences. Accelerated Rehabilitative Diversionary court, or ARD, is used to rehabilitate first-time offenders of nonviolent offenses who have not yet made crime a way of life.

It’s most often used to resolve DUI cases and other minor nonviolent offenses and includes rigorous educational programming designed to rehabilitate defendants.

Prosecutors usually agree to withdraw charges against a defendant if they successfully complete the program, which allows defendants to petition the court to expunge their case. Stoltzfus applied for the program in August 2025, and the Lancaster County District Attorney’s Office rejected him in October. He asked for reconsideration, which was rejected in February, setting the case back on track for court.

The Lancaster County District Attorney’s Office said it would not allow Stoltzfus into the program because the program can legally enforce a ban on owning or possessing dogs for only up to two years.

A felony conviction, however, could net a seven-year ban each, according to District Attorney Heather Adams.

“This longer period is best for ensuring the behavior does not occur again,” Adams told PennLive.

A ‘global solution’

Diversionary court programs vary across Pennsylvania. Some counties offer mental health court, drug court, and some, like Dauphin County, offer diversionary veteran’s court to address county-specific needs.

So why can’t Lancaster County, which has the biggest per-capita population of Amish than anywhere else in America, have an Amish diversionary court? It’s a question Barnes raises.

Diversionary court isn’t the perfect vehicle to further outreach efforts into the Amish community, Adams said. She applauded the idea but said there is no way for the probation department to supervise and enforce the requirements of the program.

“The SPCA may have interest in doing outreach or may already have some kind of outreach,” Adams said.

Barnes said: “The Amish are eager to comply with the law and have proven that over centuries so long as it’s consistent with their religious principals.”

Barnes and Geyer are pushing for a “global solution” that educates insular pockets within the Amish community on what the law says about euthanasia. They’re suggesting the district attorney’s office collaborate with them on outreach.

“We’re happy to bridge gaps, but we can’t do it if we’re going to trial in every case,” Barnes said.

“The Lancaster County DA’s office is waging a legal war on the Amish,” Barnes said. “They’re unwilling to extend to the Amish things they extend to those accused of real crimes.”

Barnes and Geyer plan to file motions to dismiss the case based on religious discrimination around the application of diversionary court.

“We have been quiet about this to afford the opportunity for the DA to do the right thing,” Barnes said. “If it goes to trial, there will be legal issues for appeal if he’s found guilty. There’s a very high chance of acquittal in the case.”

Adams said her office is standing by the charges filed: “This case is particularly troubling as Lancaster County sees a lot of animal abuse surrounding the sale of dogs,” Adams told Penn-Live.

SHARE Share Button Share Button SHARE